SANTA ANA — A state appeals court panel Monday affirmed the conviction of a mother who dropped her 7-month-old son from a Children’s Hospital of Orange County parking structure a decade ago, but sent the case back to a judge to consider whether the woman’s mental illness should weigh in favor of a probation sentence rather than life in prison.
Sonia Hermosillo of La Habra was sentenced in May 2022 to 25 years to life in prison for killing her son, Noe. But while the Fourth District Court of Appeal justices found that the jury rightly convicted Hermosillo, who had pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, they faulted Orange County Superior Court Judge Kimberly Menninger for not taking mental illness into account when considering probation as an alternative sentence.
“The grim and paradoxical reality of our system of justice is that it is sometimes unable to deliver a result which feels truly just to all involved,” Associate Justice William Bedsworth wrote in the ruling. “This case provides an especially heartbreaking illustration.”
The defendant “was by all accounts a doting mother to her two young daughters and a wonderful wife and homemaker for her husband, Noe,” Bedsworth wrote.
“When she became pregnant with a baby boy, the couple was excited, as they had been wanting a boy for some time. The baby, Noe Jr., was born late term in January 2011 and due to his over-gestation, had several physical challenges which required medical care and therapy.”
His mother “diligently” took her son to his appointments but her “behavior completely changed” when he was a few months old, Bedsworth wrote.
“She began acting very strange,” he wrote.
Hermosillo was taken to mental health professionals, but the family could not afford the treatment and her mental health deteriorated.
Hermosillo dropped her son from a parking structure at the hospital in Orange Aug. 22, 2011. Experts for the defense testified during her trial that she suffered…
Read the full article here